Engagement
Rings
The ring that starts a lifetime together. We've been helping West Michigan couples find — and create — the perfect engagement ring for 135 years.
Engagement Ring Styles
From classic solitaires to custom one-of-a-kind designs — every style, every budget, every love story.
Solitaire
The timeless classic. A single diamond held by four or six prongs — pure, elegant, and enduring. The solitaire lets the diamond speak for itself.
Halo
A center stone surrounded by a ring of smaller diamonds, amplifying its brilliance and creating a larger visual presence. One of the most popular styles today.
Three Stone
Past, present, and future. Three stones in a row — typically a larger center flanked by two smaller stones — carrying deep symbolic meaning.
Pavé
Small diamonds set closely together along the band, creating a continuous sparkle. Often combined with solitaire or halo center settings.
Vintage / Antique
Inspired by Georgian, Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras — intricate milgrain details, filigree work, and old-world romance.
Bezel Set
The diamond is encircled by a rim of metal rather than prongs — a sleek, modern look that also provides excellent stone protection.
Tension Set
The diamond appears to float between two ends of the band, held by pressure rather than prongs. A striking, architectural choice.
Custom
None of the above quite fits? We design completely custom engagement rings from scratch — your vision, your story, your ring.
The Metal Guide
Platinum
The most prestigious metal for engagement rings. Platinum is naturally white, extremely durable, and hypoallergenic. It's denser than gold and holds prongs more securely over time. The preferred choice for heirloom-quality rings.
Key Advantages
- ◆Naturally white — never yellows
- ◆Extremely durable and dense
- ◆Hypoallergenic
- ◆Prongs stay tight longer
Why West Michigan Proposes
with Siegel
We've been part of more West Michigan proposals than we can count. Couples come to us not just for the ring — but for the experience of finding it. There's no pressure, no commission-driven upselling, and no confusion.
Our GIA-certified gemologists will walk you through every option, explain every trade-off, and help you find the ring that's right for your partner and your budget. We'd rather you leave with the perfect ring at $2,000 than an okay ring at $5,000.
Book Your Consultation
A private, no-pressure appointment with one of our gemologists. We'll show you diamonds, discuss styles, and help you find exactly what you're looking for.
Mon–Fri 10am–5:30pm · Sat 10am–3pm
Six Things Every Proposer Should Know
135 years of helping people propose has taught us a few things. Here's what we wish every customer knew before they started shopping.
Know Her Style
Pay attention to the jewelry she already wears. Does she prefer yellow or white metal? Simple or ornate? Classic or modern? Her existing jewelry is the best clue.
Get the Right Size
The average women's ring size is 6–6.5, but sizes vary widely. Borrow a ring she already wears on her ring finger, or ask a close friend or family member. We can always resize after the proposal.
Prioritize Cut Over Size
A well-cut 1-carat diamond will outsparkle a poorly-cut 1.5-carat stone every time. Cut quality is the most important factor in a diamond's beauty.
Consider Her Lifestyle
An active person who works with her hands may prefer a lower-profile setting that won't snag. A more formal lifestyle might suit a dramatic halo or elevated solitaire.
Don't Overthink It
The most important thing is the moment, not the ring. We've never met a person who said no because the ring wasn't perfect. Your love and intention matter most.
Bring a Trusted Friend
If you're unsure about her taste, bring her best friend or a family member who knows her style. Just make sure they can keep a secret.
Caring for Your Engagement Ring
An engagement ring is meant to be worn every day for a lifetime. With the right care, it will look as brilliant on your 50th anniversary as it did the day you said yes.
Learn about our repair & care servicesClean Weekly
A quick soak in warm water with a drop of dish soap, followed by a soft brush, removes the oils and lotions that dull diamond brilliance. Bring it to us for a professional clean anytime — it's free.
Remove for Activities
Remove your ring before swimming (chlorine weakens metal), gardening, heavy lifting, and applying lotions or perfumes. A ring dish by the sink is a good habit.
Annual Inspection
Prongs wear down over time. An annual inspection catches loose stones before they're lost. We offer free prong checks for all Siegel customers.
Insure Your Ring
Add your engagement ring to your homeowner's or renter's insurance, or get a dedicated jewelry insurance policy. The peace of mind is worth the small annual premium.
Engagement Ring FAQs
BOGO Half Off
Wedding Bands
Buy one wedding band, get the second at 50% off. Mix and match styles — his & hers, any metal, any design. In-store only.
Koli Mitogo
I've been to many jewelry stores over the years, but Siegel Jewelers is in a class of their own. The staff remembered my name on my second visit, helped me find the perfect anniversary gift within my budget, and even gift-wrapped it beautifully. This is what shopping should feel like.
2 weeks ago
Sarah M.
My fiancé proposed with a ring from Siegel and I couldn't be more in love with it. The diamond is absolutely stunning and the setting is exactly what I'd always dreamed of. The team helped him pick something perfect without me knowing — they really listened to what he described about my style.
1 month ago
James K.
Brought in a family heirloom ring for repair and restoration. The craftsmanship on the repair was impeccable — you can't tell it was ever damaged. They also cleaned and polished it at no extra charge. The ring looks better than it has in decades.
3 weeks ago
Emily R.
I was completely overwhelmed trying to choose an engagement ring on my own. The team at Siegel spent two hours with me, never rushing, explaining every option. I left with a ring I'm obsessed with and a much better understanding of diamonds. Worth every penny.
2 months ago
Michael T.
Six generations of family ownership shows in every interaction. The knowledge, the care, the attention to detail — it's unlike any other jewelry store I've visited. They treated my $800 purchase with the same respect as someone spending $8,000.
5 months ago
Amanda B.
The custom design process was incredible. They took my rough sketch and turned it into the most beautiful ring I've ever seen. The CAD preview was spot-on, and the finished piece exceeded my expectations. I get compliments every single day.
3 months ago
Brian W.
I've been a Siegel customer for 15 years. Every purchase has been perfect, every repair flawless, every interaction warm and professional. This is the only jewelry store I'll ever recommend to friends and family in Grand Rapids.
6 weeks ago
Natalie R.
I brought in my grandmother's ring to be redesigned into something I could wear every day. The custom design team was incredible — they kept the sentimental stones and created something modern and stunning. I cry every time I look at it.
4 months ago
Tom H.
Bought my wife's engagement ring here 20 years ago and just came back for our anniversary. The service is exactly the same — warm, knowledgeable, and never pushy. A true Grand Rapids institution.
7 months ago
Lindsey P.
I was nervous about buying jewelry for the first time but the team made me feel so comfortable. They explained everything about the 4 Cs, showed me options in my budget, and never made me feel judged. Left with a gorgeous necklace and a huge smile.
3 weeks ago
Marcus D.
The Sunshine Guarantee alone sold me — but the experience sealed it. The staff spent over an hour with me, never rushing, helping me find the perfect ring for my proposal. She said yes, and we're both obsessed with the ring.
1 month ago
Carrie S.
Siegel resized my ring same day and cleaned it for free while I waited. The jeweler even pointed out a prong that was starting to wear and fixed it at no charge. This is what real customer care looks like.
2 months ago
Derek & Jenna F.
We designed our wedding bands completely from scratch. The process was so fun — they walked us through every metal, every finish, every engraving option. The final result was beyond what we imagined. Truly one-of-a-kind.
8 months ago
Patricia L.
I've been shopping at Siegel for 30 years and the quality has never wavered. My daughter just got engaged and of course we went straight to Siegel. Watching her try on rings in the same store where I bought my own was a very special moment.
5 months ago
Ryan O.
I was completely lost when it came to buying an engagement ring. The team at Siegel walked me through everything with zero pressure. I ended up with a GIA-certified diamond that was better quality and lower price than anything I'd seen online. Couldn't be happier.
6 weeks ago
Koli Mitogo
I've been to many jewelry stores over the years, but Siegel Jewelers is in a class of their own. The staff remembered my name on my second visit, helped me find the perfect anniversary gift within my budget, and even gift-wrapped it beautifully. This is what shopping should feel like.
2 weeks ago
Sarah M.
My fiancé proposed with a ring from Siegel and I couldn't be more in love with it. The diamond is absolutely stunning and the setting is exactly what I'd always dreamed of. The team helped him pick something perfect without me knowing — they really listened to what he described about my style.
1 month ago
James K.
Brought in a family heirloom ring for repair and restoration. The craftsmanship on the repair was impeccable — you can't tell it was ever damaged. They also cleaned and polished it at no extra charge. The ring looks better than it has in decades.
3 weeks ago
Emily R.
I was completely overwhelmed trying to choose an engagement ring on my own. The team at Siegel spent two hours with me, never rushing, explaining every option. I left with a ring I'm obsessed with and a much better understanding of diamonds. Worth every penny.
2 months ago
Michael T.
Six generations of family ownership shows in every interaction. The knowledge, the care, the attention to detail — it's unlike any other jewelry store I've visited. They treated my $800 purchase with the same respect as someone spending $8,000.
5 months ago
Amanda B.
The custom design process was incredible. They took my rough sketch and turned it into the most beautiful ring I've ever seen. The CAD preview was spot-on, and the finished piece exceeded my expectations. I get compliments every single day.
3 months ago
Brian W.
I've been a Siegel customer for 15 years. Every purchase has been perfect, every repair flawless, every interaction warm and professional. This is the only jewelry store I'll ever recommend to friends and family in Grand Rapids.
6 weeks ago
Natalie R.
I brought in my grandmother's ring to be redesigned into something I could wear every day. The custom design team was incredible — they kept the sentimental stones and created something modern and stunning. I cry every time I look at it.
4 months ago
Tom H.
Bought my wife's engagement ring here 20 years ago and just came back for our anniversary. The service is exactly the same — warm, knowledgeable, and never pushy. A true Grand Rapids institution.
7 months ago
Lindsey P.
I was nervous about buying jewelry for the first time but the team made me feel so comfortable. They explained everything about the 4 Cs, showed me options in my budget, and never made me feel judged. Left with a gorgeous necklace and a huge smile.
3 weeks ago
Marcus D.
The Sunshine Guarantee alone sold me — but the experience sealed it. The staff spent over an hour with me, never rushing, helping me find the perfect ring for my proposal. She said yes, and we're both obsessed with the ring.
1 month ago
Carrie S.
Siegel resized my ring same day and cleaned it for free while I waited. The jeweler even pointed out a prong that was starting to wear and fixed it at no charge. This is what real customer care looks like.
2 months ago
Derek & Jenna F.
We designed our wedding bands completely from scratch. The process was so fun — they walked us through every metal, every finish, every engraving option. The final result was beyond what we imagined. Truly one-of-a-kind.
8 months ago
Patricia L.
I've been shopping at Siegel for 30 years and the quality has never wavered. My daughter just got engaged and of course we went straight to Siegel. Watching her try on rings in the same store where I bought my own was a very special moment.
5 months ago
Ryan O.
I was completely lost when it came to buying an engagement ring. The team at Siegel walked me through everything with zero pressure. I ended up with a GIA-certified diamond that was better quality and lower price than anything I'd seen online. Couldn't be happier.
6 weeks ago
Koli Mitogo
I've been to many jewelry stores over the years, but Siegel Jewelers is in a class of their own. The staff remembered my name on my second visit, helped me find the perfect anniversary gift within my budget, and even gift-wrapped it beautifully. This is what shopping should feel like.
2 weeks ago
Sarah M.
My fiancé proposed with a ring from Siegel and I couldn't be more in love with it. The diamond is absolutely stunning and the setting is exactly what I'd always dreamed of. The team helped him pick something perfect without me knowing — they really listened to what he described about my style.
1 month ago
James K.
Brought in a family heirloom ring for repair and restoration. The craftsmanship on the repair was impeccable — you can't tell it was ever damaged. They also cleaned and polished it at no extra charge. The ring looks better than it has in decades.
3 weeks ago
Emily R.
I was completely overwhelmed trying to choose an engagement ring on my own. The team at Siegel spent two hours with me, never rushing, explaining every option. I left with a ring I'm obsessed with and a much better understanding of diamonds. Worth every penny.
2 months ago
Michael T.
Six generations of family ownership shows in every interaction. The knowledge, the care, the attention to detail — it's unlike any other jewelry store I've visited. They treated my $800 purchase with the same respect as someone spending $8,000.
5 months ago
Amanda B.
The custom design process was incredible. They took my rough sketch and turned it into the most beautiful ring I've ever seen. The CAD preview was spot-on, and the finished piece exceeded my expectations. I get compliments every single day.
3 months ago
Brian W.
I've been a Siegel customer for 15 years. Every purchase has been perfect, every repair flawless, every interaction warm and professional. This is the only jewelry store I'll ever recommend to friends and family in Grand Rapids.
6 weeks ago
Natalie R.
I brought in my grandmother's ring to be redesigned into something I could wear every day. The custom design team was incredible — they kept the sentimental stones and created something modern and stunning. I cry every time I look at it.
4 months ago
Tom H.
Bought my wife's engagement ring here 20 years ago and just came back for our anniversary. The service is exactly the same — warm, knowledgeable, and never pushy. A true Grand Rapids institution.
7 months ago
Lindsey P.
I was nervous about buying jewelry for the first time but the team made me feel so comfortable. They explained everything about the 4 Cs, showed me options in my budget, and never made me feel judged. Left with a gorgeous necklace and a huge smile.
3 weeks ago
Marcus D.
The Sunshine Guarantee alone sold me — but the experience sealed it. The staff spent over an hour with me, never rushing, helping me find the perfect ring for my proposal. She said yes, and we're both obsessed with the ring.
1 month ago
Carrie S.
Siegel resized my ring same day and cleaned it for free while I waited. The jeweler even pointed out a prong that was starting to wear and fixed it at no charge. This is what real customer care looks like.
2 months ago
Derek & Jenna F.
We designed our wedding bands completely from scratch. The process was so fun — they walked us through every metal, every finish, every engraving option. The final result was beyond what we imagined. Truly one-of-a-kind.
8 months ago
Patricia L.
I've been shopping at Siegel for 30 years and the quality has never wavered. My daughter just got engaged and of course we went straight to Siegel. Watching her try on rings in the same store where I bought my own was a very special moment.
5 months ago
Ryan O.
I was completely lost when it came to buying an engagement ring. The team at Siegel walked me through everything with zero pressure. I ended up with a GIA-certified diamond that was better quality and lower price than anything I'd seen online. Couldn't be happier.
6 weeks ago